This was a Career vs. Career match.
For those uninitiated, maybe those to never read the praise of some of my peers for this match, you may be asking who exactly Metalico is.
Metalico is a longtime CMLL midcarder, who never really did much higher up the card. The mid to late 90s through 2009 are sort of a blind spot for me as far as lucha goes, but even through the last decade, I would struggle to name a single time I’ve seen him. He is not especially distinctive in his looks outside of a pencil thin mustache. His physique is not great, a classic middle aged sort of guy, his gear is ordinary, and while this match clearly shows that he’s real far from being a bum, he is not the sort of guy you might call an overwhelming talent. In a match not explicitly about him, he would not stand out.
This is usually where I would say “none of that matters”, but that’s not the case here.
It does matter.
All of it matters, because that’s what makes this match.
People have argued — and will continue to argue forever — about what the most important aspect of wrestling is. It’s sort of a hard thing to do, because really, it’s all connected. A truly great match is rarely great just because of force of narrative or pure mechanics alone, there’s a cooperation between the two more often than not, but the difference between matches I like and matches I love comes down to pure feeling, and this match has so much of it.
So few matches tend to get there for me that I often spend time here talking about the more quantifiable aspects of a match, focusing on quality mechanics or great performance quirks, but this is a match not only wrestled with real feeling, but that really really got me. Not everybody is going to be hit in the same way by the same stuff, one of my favorite matches of the decade has that status because it is an old man bowing out that happened within the same month that my father passed away, and I would never expect anyone else to love it like I do a a result. This isn’t quite that, but likewise, I cannot expect everyone to see what I saw in it, to like it like I did, or to latch on in the same way.
Hearts and minds are curious things, and what holds true for mine may not hold quite as true for yours, and all of that.
The thing is, show me “underappreciated reliable workhorse makes good”, and I am completely in. I love that stuff. Catnip. Dirtbags achieving things, unassuming guys doing their best under an uncommonly large spotlight, I adore it. Couple it with a major apuestas (lack of hair on the line or not, this is still a wager), the feeling of said guy also fighting for his livelihood, and I am completely hooked.
All this match really has to do is to live up to that, and it does so much more.
Metalico, individually, is fantastic.
The desperation pouring out of him at every second is so great, and feels so real. He seems like someone on edge for the entirety of the match, doing his best but weirdly, also like someone who knows he is up against it and prepared for something to go wrong. Beyond the way he carries himself, his actions in the match also do a lot to further the idea, both on purpose and not. Part of that is the gigantic stuff he breaks out nearly from the start, like the missile dropkick off the apron that’s one of my favorite moves in wrestling, only ever used by the most under-the-gun psychos in wrestling. The way the match has him (and Virus too, to be fair) both get dirtier and more frantic as the match goes on — going from fairly clean wrestling to covering each other’s eyes in holds or going low or throwing in cheap punches in the back half — is also perfect, not only for an apuestas in general, but for one with these stakes. The dying of the light and things of that nature. There are also less obviously planned things that add a whole lot, like how Metalico’s first tope is gorgeous and impactful and hits perfectly, but his second one near the end barely goes through and sees him just hit Virus with a headbutt to the face, almost coming up short.
Virus is Virus.
There’s not as much with him because, at least to me, he is much more of a known quantity. He does things he always does well. Smooth movements, beautiful base work, stellar reactions to everything, all of that. He is the control group in this match, the baseline that makes the other stuff stand out, the foundation on which to build, but he is as great at that as always.
Where the match really succeeds, of course, is the gut punch that hits about midway through (I am an optimist) that for Metalico, it is never going to be enough. With his nerves on edge and spending twenty minutes walking on the edge of a knife, even throwing out the biggest stuff he can think of, he is not only less practiced in matches of this caliber than Virus is, but he is also just less skilled. He can unload with a flurry of hands, but Virus can drop him with one right. He can do all of the most sensational stuff in the world, but he lacks the real high end offense that Virus has. He’s never a sitting duck, he meets his end standing and fighting it every step of the way, even creating that ultra impressive and powerful well MAYBE when he kicks out of a few big pieces of offense like the near Kudo Driver of Virus, but it is never in doubt.
Virus makes Metalico submit to a near Scorpion Cross Lock, and Metalico retires, as he was always going to.
The joy of this match is not in the result, but in the process, and in the performance. A career midcarder, maybe an underachiever standing up in the last ever chance to do so not only putting on a show but being so appreciated in those final moments for it. Someone closer to normal, closer to the rest of us than so many of the big heroes in wrestling, wrestling outside of himself for one night and standing up to achieve something special, even in defeat. Fighting against the inevitable, because what else is there to do? It’s beautiful stuff, once again proving that the best wrestling matches are more than just matches.
A genuine triumph, taking a charming little premise and going as far as possible with it to create something genuinely moving, resulting in not only one of the most memorable matches of the year, but one of the very best as well.
***1/2