This was a commissioned review from Corwo. You can be like them and pay me to write about anything you would like also, be it a match, a series of matches, a show, or whatever. The going price is $5/match (or if you want a TV show or movie, $5 per half hour), obviously make sure I haven’t covered it before (and ideally come with a link). If that sounds like a thing you’d like to do, head on over to www.ko-fi.com/elhijodelsimon and do that. If you have an idea more complex than just listing matches and multiplying a number by five, feel free to hit the DMs and we can work something out.
This was a mask vs. mask match, and as far as those go, is one of the more famous and celebrated ones of the last, I don’t know, half century maybe.
It is great.
Really really really really great. Transcendently so. In a lesser year, it would be the runaway no-other-candidates answer for Match of the Year, and even in a year as stacked as 2000, it’s not an answer I would have any real argument against, and may even choose for myself one day. You could call it the best match of the decade, and again, sure, fine. It’s remarkably great, to the point that when it was over, I felt the need to watch it again.
You watch it once for the experience, and another time to try and reckon with it, in some attempt to put words to a thing like this.
I do not imagine many of you are reading this — both on account of the readership of this blog, and of the numbers even famous lucha matches do, sort of a self selecting thing — who have not seen this and love it already, or at the very least, have not heard about this in some form. Be that as something other people have praised in video, audio, or text form, or something that even lucha fledglings or the lucha ignorant know about for awards it’s won or for the status it has as this huge box office hit (biggest Arena Mexico number of the twenty first century, no big deal). It’s a match with a reputation, to put it lightly.
Still.
Still.
What a match.
There are a few different elements of this that I really loved.
Independent of anything that Atlantis or Villano III does in this match, the way that this is presented is unbelievable.
Part of that has to do with one of the great atmospheres in wrestling history.
Arena Mexico is more than full here, twenty thousand people hooting and hollering and loudly pouring their guts out just the same as Atlantis and Villano III. Every single thing in this match gets a huge reaction, every possible hold and pinning combination is reacted to it like it could be it, and along with the way the two wrestlers in the match perform and react to these moves (more on that later), it makes everything feel a thousand times bigger and more important than it might had things been different.
The way this is filmed and presented is even better though, and genuinely may be my actual favorite part of the match. Certainly, it’s what leapt off the page on the first viewing of the match, not only capturing all of the action perfectly, but doing it in all of these really interesting ways too, not only with these cool perspective shots, always finding fun new angles to show the blood soaking Atlantis’ mask, making the dives feel as big and exciting as possible, but also in the way they approach small things before the match really gets moving,
CMLL’s presentation of the atmosphere on top of the action is a significant help too. There may be no greater example in wrestling history of a show of fans throughout the match than this one. They cut away to just about every demographic you can think of from old men to children to young couples to middle aged women to, you know, you fucking name it, they’re all here, twenty thousand of ’em. They’re making all of these different faces and reactions too, from wild exhuberant cheering for their guy to pure horror, to my favorite, an old man looking on with the greatest look of concern I’ve maybe ever seen a fan have. The camera slowly zooms back out to see him surrounded by more excited younger people, and it is not at all hard to imagine this man as a long time Villano III fan, maybe a Ray Mendoza fan before that, living and dying with this stuff, and that adds so so so so much to the experience.
As a full package, it is a masterclass in wrestling presentation and production — showing the scope of the event, as well as displaying the action in interesting and novel ways, creating a greater sense of importance and feeling — and one that I think really ought to be studied. That’s the sort of thing people say about great old matches or great old mechanical performances, people always ought to study Arn or Manny Fernandez or whoever, but with a total and complete package like this, it goes just as much for the other side of the camera too.
When combined with the way in which the action is shot, the effect is that this is transformed into more than just a high stakes wrestling match. The old bit was always that it’s a sport outside of America (which always felt a little woe-is-me to me, whatever, stop crying and watch), but has rarely felt quite so true as it does here. It is less a wrestling match on film than it is a genuine event, a happening that the world poured out en masse to bare witness to.
The kicker is, on top of all of that, the match — this monumental event that they’ve all come to see — is also incredible.
It’s on a level not just beyond most other apuestas matches of the twenty first century to date, but beyond most other apuestas matches ever, with only one other coming to mind as a potential rival, and I’m not really sure off the top of my head which one I would go with in the end. This isn’t the raw and violent kind of fistfight I often prefer my lucha bloodbaths to be, but they manage to have this kind of a pure back and forth apuestas style match with the same kind of guttural feeling, which is maybe the most impressive thing of all. It is one of the more dramatic contests in wrestling history, but that feeling is largely achieved with two dives and a lot of holds and simpler maneuvers.
Largely, this is achieved because Atlantis and Villano III put on one of the greatest displays of the idea of Wrestling Big that I’ve ever seen. Every single thing in this match feels like it matters to both wrestlers in it, and once the big Villano III tope suicida happens and they crack heads, opening each other up, every single movement in this match feels like life or death. The dive itself is a perfect kind of lucha morality tale in and of itself, even though this is not a match with a super clear hero and villain story, with the overzealousness of the older star costing him, not only in the moment, but arguably in a longer-term sense, the contest itself. The match can be praised for the way everything flows perfectly into the next thing and a jaw-dropping economy of movement, in which everything is treated as important by everyone involved, but there is such a struggle that happens with every single thing in it that helps it further that feeling. Every hold comes with an attempt to fight out as quickly as possible, but also this sense of panic. Every moment once they’re both cut open has a sense of desperation to it, and maybe more impressively than just that, a desperation that flows back and forth as the match goes on, from moment to moment.
Genuinely, it feels less like a wrestling match sometimes and more like something greater, game seven in a championship series, but with a tangible punishment for the loser as well. It’s the sort of feeling that only professional wrestling can really ever recreate, and that it so often fails to even try for, let alone achieve.
Villano III pulls off what feels nearly impossible, and escapes from La Atlantida. In the attempt though, his back is too hurt for him to do much, and this time, Atlantis follows through with a little more force and a lot more intensity.
On the second attempt, Atlantis’ La Atlantida, now complete with drop down to avoid the escape, succeeds and Villano III surrenders his mask.
Following the match, one of the more emotional mask removal ceremonies ever takes place. Villano III is maybe not a wrestler I loved as much as I did Blue Panther or that I do some others (Atlantis now among them, as a result of seeing his early 90s and 2010s work around this match), but when his father Ray Mendoza gets in there with him for the embrace, along with his brothers, and an infant in his arms, it’s real hard not to feel at least a little something. Villano III hands his mask over to Atlantis, and while it’s a little late in both directions to be some kind of real passing of the torch, it sure doesn’t feel like nothing either.
Maybe the best lucha match I’ve ever seen (if not the best, then certainly top two or three), and in case that is a little too restrictive for you, one of the best matches of all time period.
Having said that, just in case newer eyes are reading this one, I don’t think just anybody can jump in here.
I don’t want this to be anybody’s first lucha match.
These big mask matches should never be. The first lucha match, save things like the When World Collides tag that was on a WWE DVD and some recommended 90s stuff, was the famous Blue Panther vs. Villano V mask match in 2008. A great match, even to a stylistic novice, but it was something I saw without the connection needed to get the most out of it (a great match, but one I rejected the MOTY praise for at the time, going with the other two of 2008’s Big Three — the BattlARTS six man and Fire Ant vs. Vin Gerard respectfully — instead), and simultaneously, it raised the bar just a little too high for everything else, accomplishing little more than forever making me go ”oh, yeah, I love Blue Panther”. When nothing else was as good, I fell back out of trying to regularly watch lucha for another decade or so, before really committing to it during the pandemic. I imagine this could perform much the same way for many of the same reasons, if not moreso.
Watch a lot of Villano III. Watch even more Atlantis, past and future. Maybe even do what I didn’t quite get to do here, and that I would have done if this wasn’t bought and paid for, and watch through the entire build up to this match, which isn’t too hard to find online these days. When you’re ready, this is going to be there waiting for you with its arms wide open and fists curled up and cocked back. I cannot imagine it disappointing a single person on Earth who was ready to see it, given how far it stands above just about everything else.
A genuine monolith.
****1/3