Kevin Owens vs. Sami Zayn vs. The Miz vs. Dolph Ziggler vs. Stardust vs. Zack Ryder vs. Sin Cara II, WWE WrestleMania 32 (4/3/2016)

This was a ladder match for Big Kev’s WWE Intercontinental Title.

I’ve always had a weakness for a decent enough version of this match. Part of that is because it’s clearly WWE’s attempt at a make-good for all the wrestlers that they know are good or great enough to be on the biggest show of the year (and on the main card, not some battle royal or pre-show thing) but that they’re too lazy and/or inept to really come up for anything else for. There’s something especially depressing about the implied “hey sorry, maybe next time” that comes with a match like this that always makes me real sympathetic towards something like this on a WrestleMania.

Also I like cool spots and these matches are a parade of some very cool spots.

I could write a little bit here about the mix of styles and characters that makes matches like these work at a high-ish level when all goes right, and that’s not something that’s absent here. You have your coward type, your fighter who is pretending to be tough but is also kind of a coward in Big Kev, a few great likeable white meat babyfaces, a total weirdo, things like that.

Honestly though, the trick here is that for the first time in one of these, two of the wildest ladder match wrestlers of the last decade are unleashed in a match like this in the WWE, and Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn do a whole bunch of really remarkable and totally outrageous stuff, while also largely being the focus of the match as a story. Some of it is new, but mostly, they’re just bigger and more fantastic and impressive versions of the stuff from something like the Ladder War like eight and a half years earlier.

All match long, our favorite duo are constantly sniping at each other. Delightfully, even in moments when one is out of the frame, they just can never really help themselves. Owens constantly goes after Sami, like he’s trying to pre-empt the sort of thing he instinctually knows is going to happen. In doing so, he turns a paranoid feeling into an absolute guarantee, as wrestling’s greatest vicious cycle continues, with neither man knowing quite how to close it or possessing the desire to close it.

Kevin Owens nearly makes it to the end, only for Zayn to reappear, and take him entirely out of the match with another one of their classic ladder spots.

This match isn’t JUST about Kev and Sami, there’s some other fun stuff. The polka dot ladder, a great Ziggler run in the middle, one big and sensational dive out of Sin Cara II. Everyone gets the chance to do something, and outside of the awful Stardust gimmick, there’s not really a truly weak link here.

The Miz is just about to sneak away with it, but gets exactly cocky enough without anyone to watch his back for Zack Ryder to take him out and get the title.

It’s a nice little result. A feel good victory, and like a lot of the match itself, a kind of make-good to the company a solid four years late after how horribly they fucked him once upon a time. Given how well things turned out for the guy after his WWE tenure eventually ended, it doesn’t feel QUITE as good as it’s no longer like this one bright little moment, but it’s still nice. More importantly, it’s a nice moment that comes largely from out of nowhere, this one little glimmer on an otherwise deeply depressing event that shows that somewhere deep down there, there’s some knowledge of how this thing is supposed to work, or at least how it can work.

Unfortunately this Kev/Sami ladder match with a feel good result doesn’t result in Super Dragon’s return, but given how much this match got right, you can only ever expect so much from this company.

The match of the night, for whatever that matters on a show like this.

***

The New Day vs. The Usos vs. The Lucha Dragons, WWE TLC (12/13/2015)

This was a ladder match for the New Day’s WWE World Tag Team Titles.

It’s a big dumb stunt show and I absolutely love it.

The trick is both a total honesty about that and also the ability to fill the match with big spot ideas that are both incredibly cool and fairly novel. This match also makes clear distinctions between the teams and wrestlers in the match in interesting ways (Big E is strong, Kalisto is the littlest but has the craziest brain, The Usos need to work in tandem to succeed), and it allows for some tension and struggle at all times. Everyone tries to take Big E out, and it always allows the space for Kofi Kingston to sneak around and so some stuff, and it’s how New Day hangs on despite this match being wildly out of the element of half the line up that they went with in this match. It’s a nice touch, and the sort of thought a match like this needs put into it to exist on a level beyond just shouting “COOL!” over and over for fifteen minutes and to stay in my mind for years like this has.

The one major spot also helps out, and if you’ve seen the match, I don’t even have to say more than that.

For the children though:

It’s the high point of the match, but not the end.

With Kalisto and That Uso being taken out, the other tries to handle Big E for good with an equally God damning splash off the top to Big E under a ladder lying on the floor. It’s the same sort of a move that removes someone at the price of also removing yourself, and shows the value Big E brings even when he can’t climb. The pro wrestling version of the gravity that a great shooter in basketball or a great receiver in football gives you. Kalisto manages to get up, as Sin Cara II has just somehow vanished, but Woods gets on the apron and delightfully hurls the trombone at his back. He’s distracted, and Kofi hurls him flipping off the ladder in another wholly unnecessary and wonderful bump, before Kofi pulls down the weird thing the belts are on in WWE and nowhere else.

A great match, but historically, largely a framework for one of the greatest spots of all time.

It’s a god damner of a thing, the sort of spot that belongs in highlight reels for years and years and years (obviously you feature and retain the sort of talent who can do this…). Like the match itself, if the WWE had any idea of how to canonize their history, or if they cared to, this would have a far greater reputation than it does. Better matches than this have suffered from the same problem, but it’s always a little bit of a bummer when you finish a great WWE pay per view match and come to that same realization.

If nothing else, the one spot at least seems to have had some staying power, which is more than you can usually say for a match like this.

***1/4